When we build our landscape around places to go, we lose places to be. -Rick Cole
2011/02/20
2011/02/15
2011/02/14

Norfolk map and Paris map which was inspired by Guy Debords frustration of how the medieval streets of paris had been torn down in order to build the Haussmans boulevards and large transportation systems which controlled the way in which people moved around the city.
"Haussmann’s Paris is a city built by an idiot, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing. Present-day urbanism’s main problem is ensuring the smooth circulation of a rapidly increasing number of motor vehicles. A future urbanism will undoubtedly apply itself to no less utilitarian projects, but in the rather different context of psychogeographical possibilities." Guy Debord, Les Lèvres Nues #6 (September 1955).
In these works I wanted to try collage the parisienne boulevards with the reletivly untouched lands of Norfolk- my birth home to try to personally understand the effect of large transportation networks. and urban planning. The scale of the Parision map is much larger than the Norfolk one but maybe shares simular scales to the disstructive developement of new cities in China. It seems that the third world are not learning from the mistakes in urban planning.
2011/02/01
2011/01/19
2011/01/18
Jan the man Gehl
I attended a lecture presented by Jan Gehl, running through the themes of his new book "Cities for People". Having seen a lecture by Enrique Penalosa the week before I was still thinking about all the ideas and policies that he had spoken about. I kind of knew what to expect from the lecture having read some Jan Gehl’s of books already.
The main focus of the lecture was obviously about how cars dominate space in our cities and how they destroy human interaction and the general quality of the built environment.
I was surprised that Jan Gehl talked about how the planners and architects over the past 50 years had neglected the human scale of the city, instead pursuing pointless perversities within their art.
For town planners he described an obsession with aerial views at enormous scales where designers stood around arranging perfect geometric compositions and skylines for our cities, compositions that at ground level had created the most desolate public spaces ever.
He claimed that this was also true of architecture, which in pursuit of form had lost all contact with "the life between buildings”. He used Dubai as his main example calling it a fantastic example of "birdshit planning", where buildings were seemingly just dropped (or shat) from the sky with no regard for the spaces or non spaces being created at a human level.
When it came to the turn of landscape architects ("the good guys" he said sarcastically) I was relieved to hear him say that he thought they were much the same as architects, that they had become too obsessed with form and beauty than authentic values. In fact Landscape Architects were probably worse, as they were sometimes doing the exact opposite to what they set out to do. This he highlighted by showing examples from development proposals, collages portraying new urban spaces full of life and people and then a photo of the real space (after it had been approved and built) showing the complete opposite, a deserted space.
These criticisms were followed by examples of cities such as Melbourne, Bogota and of course Denmark where urban life had been transformed by implementing the policies (reducing cars, creating an urban environment at a human scale) that Gehl and many other urban thinkers believe in.
Before going to the lecture I had spoken to a Landscape Architect who had actually been taught by Jan Gehl. He had told me that he felt frustrated with the man Jan because “he had been regurgitating the same old ideas and policies for the past 40 years”. So I went with the intention of trying to address this criticism. Jan Gehl kind of answered this himself really.
He explained that in the past 50 years from the early beginnings (Jane Jacobs) when we had started to realise that we were basically making a mess of things, to now when so many people have proven what is desperately wrong with our cities, we are still not addressing the problem and continue to fuck everything up. And I think that in our time when everything has such global resonance this is an obvious indication towards developing countries. As Gehl showed developing countries have adopted the ideologies (car and wealth dominance) that we started 50 years ago.
I couldn’t help but leave this lecture with the feeling of not wanting to become a landscape architect. It seems to me (at this moment in time) that it is an institution full of pretences and noble intentions. It stands behind policies to change our urban environment for the better and then does very little. It is the art that lies closest to the human environment, which people experience through their everyday life. And yet it challenges nothing.
I used to hate the term, but since realising how influenced by corporate power and how dominated by law it is, it seems that a large amount of landscape architects are nothing more than “glorified gardeners” who fight for scraps of space commissioned to them. Creating beautiful spaces where they are allowed to.
I’m not really sure what I’m getting at here and I’ll probably feel differently next time I see an amazing landscape project, but these are just ideas fresh after the lecture.
The main focus of the lecture was obviously about how cars dominate space in our cities and how they destroy human interaction and the general quality of the built environment.
I was surprised that Jan Gehl talked about how the planners and architects over the past 50 years had neglected the human scale of the city, instead pursuing pointless perversities within their art.
For town planners he described an obsession with aerial views at enormous scales where designers stood around arranging perfect geometric compositions and skylines for our cities, compositions that at ground level had created the most desolate public spaces ever.
He claimed that this was also true of architecture, which in pursuit of form had lost all contact with "the life between buildings”. He used Dubai as his main example calling it a fantastic example of "birdshit planning", where buildings were seemingly just dropped (or shat) from the sky with no regard for the spaces or non spaces being created at a human level.
When it came to the turn of landscape architects ("the good guys" he said sarcastically) I was relieved to hear him say that he thought they were much the same as architects, that they had become too obsessed with form and beauty than authentic values. In fact Landscape Architects were probably worse, as they were sometimes doing the exact opposite to what they set out to do. This he highlighted by showing examples from development proposals, collages portraying new urban spaces full of life and people and then a photo of the real space (after it had been approved and built) showing the complete opposite, a deserted space.
These criticisms were followed by examples of cities such as Melbourne, Bogota and of course Denmark where urban life had been transformed by implementing the policies (reducing cars, creating an urban environment at a human scale) that Gehl and many other urban thinkers believe in.
Before going to the lecture I had spoken to a Landscape Architect who had actually been taught by Jan Gehl. He had told me that he felt frustrated with the man Jan because “he had been regurgitating the same old ideas and policies for the past 40 years”. So I went with the intention of trying to address this criticism. Jan Gehl kind of answered this himself really.
He explained that in the past 50 years from the early beginnings (Jane Jacobs) when we had started to realise that we were basically making a mess of things, to now when so many people have proven what is desperately wrong with our cities, we are still not addressing the problem and continue to fuck everything up. And I think that in our time when everything has such global resonance this is an obvious indication towards developing countries. As Gehl showed developing countries have adopted the ideologies (car and wealth dominance) that we started 50 years ago.
I couldn’t help but leave this lecture with the feeling of not wanting to become a landscape architect. It seems to me (at this moment in time) that it is an institution full of pretences and noble intentions. It stands behind policies to change our urban environment for the better and then does very little. It is the art that lies closest to the human environment, which people experience through their everyday life. And yet it challenges nothing.
I used to hate the term, but since realising how influenced by corporate power and how dominated by law it is, it seems that a large amount of landscape architects are nothing more than “glorified gardeners” who fight for scraps of space commissioned to them. Creating beautiful spaces where they are allowed to.
I’m not really sure what I’m getting at here and I’ll probably feel differently next time I see an amazing landscape project, but these are just ideas fresh after the lecture.
2011/01/13
2011/01/11
'public good prevails over private interest'
went to a lecture by Enrique Penalosa (former mayor of Bogota, Columbia) who talked about the changes he has implemented in Bogota in order to make public space a safe engaging environment in which people feel the can walk and have ownership of. He talked allot about the conflict between cars and people and how transportation systems dominate and control public space. He restricts car use and takes over roads instead encouraging protected bike networks, bus routes and public space. he gives priority to public transport in road space so 'public good prevails over private interest'. The lecture was extremely interesting and Penalosa was very convincing that theres needs to be a shift in the way in which we will begin to design new cities- beginning by building quality schools and libraries. instead of transport infrastructures and shopping centres i.e spending public money on well being instead of economic gain. 'the market will not create great cities' Enrique
2010/10/23
2010/10/10
2010/09/28
2010/08/26
2010/08/12
2010/08/11
2010/08/10
2010/08/02
2010/07/27
2010/07/23
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)









